Are phone upgrades worth it?

Emily (No)

Though getting the latest cellphone is tempting, it’s better overall to fight the urge to upgrade. New phone releases are done to evoke “crav[ing] the new device even though they do not need a new one.' In reality, significant differences aren’t really noticeable between devices until about two to three years, as software updates, which phones often receive automatically, are usually all you need to improve the function of an older phone model so it feels like new.

XDA-Developers highlights past annual phone releases had notable differences. For example, the iPhone 4 added FaceTime, and the design was more modern than the iPhone 3. Today, some people cannot distinguish the differences between the iPhone 12 and 13 Pro. Smartphone designs haven’t changed much, so if a case is being used, it doesn't matter what version a person has. 

Unfortunately, frequent consumption of phones has caused our environment to suffer, as phone production is responsible for 95% of phone pollution emissions. Discarded phones continue polluting as e-waste. In 2019, 10% of global e-waste (about 50 million tons) came from smartphones alone. Phones should not be so easily discarded, as repairing or buying a refurbished phone is a vastly underutilized, more affordable, and climate-friendly option. If a phone still functions properly, there’s no reason to waste money by discarding it. Likewise, support for a phone's software is usually available for years following the initial purchase.

Finally, trading in phones to get a newer and better camera isn’t necessary as phone cameras are already so powerful. Social media platforms compress uploaded photos and videos, so people viewing the pictures won’t see them on ideal displays. Upgrading for reasons outside of functionality isn't worth the cost or collective harm it does to your wallet or the world.

Dae (Yes)

In today's fast-paced digital world, it's no secret that technology evolves rapidly. This evolution is particularly evident in the world of smartphones, where newer models hit the market with impressive regularity. Some may question the need for frequent phone upgrades, but there are compelling reasons why staying up-to-date with the latest devices is a wise choice.

Technology's relentless march forward means newer phones are equipped with faster processors, more RAM, and enhanced graphics capabilities. Upgrading to a newer phone can supercharge your device's performance, allowing for seamless multitasking, lightning-fast app loading, and an overall smoother user experience.

Each new phone generation introduces innovative features and functionalities that older devices may lack. These are just a few examples of improved camera capabilities, advanced security features like facial recognition or fingerprint scanning, extended battery life, and support for the latest software updates and apps. Manufacturers typically provide extended software support and security updates for newer phone models. By upgrading, you also ensure your device remains relevant for a longer period, receiving the latest features and patches. 

Upgrading to a newer phone can also be a savvy financial move. Newer phones tend to retain their value better in the resale market, making it easier to recoup a substantial portion of your investment when you eventually decide to upgrade again. This resale value can help offset the cost of your new device, reducing the overall cost of staying on the cutting edge. Overall, phone upgrades are not merely about having the latest gadget; they are a strategic investment in improved performance, enhanced features, extended longevity, and potential financial returns on something that is used everyday.