Should writers use AI?

Andrew (No)

Most of what we call AI isn’t actually AI. Programs like ChatGPT are large language models, which use vast amounts of data to predict what word should come next. This is fundamentally different from thinking or intelligence, which can plan complex thoughts and structures. This may seem like a technicality but consider the effect this has on writing. Large Language Models (LLMs) or “artificial intelligence” shift writing from the possible to the probable. In other words, when humans write, the process is about invention, creativity, and consciously willing into existence ideas that have not existed previously. When so-called AI writes, it simply strings together the most likely combination of words. If we leave writing to AI, we’ll never have new ideas.

AI systems are very difficult to understand, and their inner workings are quite opaque. This means their biases will be challenging to parse. When we read something written by a human we know who the author is, or can at least find out about them. AI lacks empathy and an understanding of emotion, and while an AI may make a very polished statement, its true meaning and intent may lack human context.

Finally, why would a writer want to use an AI? Grammar tools aside, if a writer delegates all of their work to a machine, they aren’t really a writer anymore. They’ve become lazy in their craft or mere computer programmers. Writing is a human skill, and the flaws and subtle inflections are part of human communication, just like with music or visual art. We’ve been putting pen to paper for thousands of years, and the results have frankly been stunning, let’s leave the machines out.

ChatGPT (Yes)

In the realm of content creation, writers are increasingly relying on artificial intelligence (AI) as an essential tool to enrich their craft. This shift is driven by the practical advantages it offers in terms of efficiency and creativity.

AI significantly enhances time efficiency by streamlining various writing tasks. Automated content generation tools swiftly produce high-quality drafts, allowing writers to focus their efforts on refining their work. Grammar and style checkers, powered by AI, provide prompt feedback and facilitate efficient content polishing. Beyond mere efficiency, AI serves as a catalyst for creativity. Writers often struggle with generating ideas, and AI steps in as a reliable muse, offering suggestions for topics and themes. Its ability to overcome creative blocks and discover novel angles proves invaluable for crafting engaging stories or articles.

Moreover, the personalized nature of AI tools contributes to a writer's professional growth. Adaptive learning features enable AI platforms to understand and adapt to individual writing styles, fostering ongoing skill enhancement. Real-time insights from these tools enable writers to continuously refine their language skills and learn from their mistakes.

AI's role extends beyond individual writers to collaborative endeavors. Collaborative writing tools, powered by AI, facilitate real-time collaboration, version control, and seamless integration of contributions from multiple authors, promoting teamwork and efficient co-authoring.

In conclusion, integrating AI into the writer's toolkit is a strategic move rooted in tangible benefits. From enhanced time efficiency and creative inspiration to personalized learning and collaborative capabilities, AI emerges as an indispensable ally for writers navigating the complexities of modern content creation. Leveraging AI is not merely an option but a pragmatic choice for those striving for excellence in their craft.